SourPuddle's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Disturbing Beauty]

Man, I've been listening to your older tunes for so long. . .When I came back, I had to check you out. Thanks man! This stuff is professional. . .Guess the market isn't exactly in your favor though, eh? I liked this piece, it's a good showing of your darker side. . .You've always had a subtle mystery about your music (as fun and playful as it is, there's always a tingle of malicious intentions!) so it's nice to see you really flesh out that feeling. And you do a great represenation:

"You're a scary paradise" for example-- you just mix the good in the bad right in the pot and bam-- add some VitranDango, keep your 80s voice, we got a great song produced, cut and sent. Thanks man! Don't stop the flow, and if you get a record deal or something, hit me up!

VitranDango responds:

Haha! Hey Sour Puddle, its been awhile! Thanks again too, I appreciate that!

Yeah, I don't think the market will ever be in my favor, haha! I think my market missed me by 30 years, haha! Even modern acts that have a vibe this similar usually have better success in Europe. Hopefully I can develop a live act one of these days.

Yeah, these lyrics are quite dark compared to most of what I do. When building the song, it started to sound deep and dark, so I just drew upon a bad relationship and it kindof fell into place. Its about misplaced sympathy, being drawn into by someone just to fulfill their own wicked needs.

I'm glad you dug the song SourPuddle, I'm kindof proud of this one, so I'm glad you dug it too.

[-MiB!- /EnDiNG\]

Pretty good

Your bass lowering all other sounds would be because the soundwaves are just that fricken big, that they're blocking out all the other sounds. The beat is good when it's consistent on four-on-the-floor (1-2-3-4-). The bass is really nice and deep, but don't over indulge the listener in it. I noticed the filter changes, too, the hi-hat sounds killer!

RandomDanceOfHappy responds:

how would i fix so said prob? i mean it fixes it if i turn it down to the point i cant hear it.
i dont get what you mean when you says four on the floor?
are you talking bout he part thats after the intro where the kicks are at every 4 and everything unlike near the ending where the kicks fallow the pattern more so thin timeing? cos that was me trying something new.
the hi hat is vary simple lol all i did was 1 had the panning go from l to r
and at the slow parts i turned on reverb!
also there where not many filter changes at all to notice XD
bass over all turned really good to me i maid them to lison with my sub and i tryed not makeing them to noticeable so they wouldent be distracting
i put alot of work in on this song and i know im not done
-MiB!-

[gud tekno song]

CAN YOU DIG IT?!

Dude, this is sexy. Everyone should listen to it at high volume.

Archealor responds:

yeah man it isn't loud enough though

[The Black Land of Shadow]

Being a Percussionist and all. . .

The entrance with the timpani and the snare. . .Was just impossible. You can't play a timpani that fast. It just wouldn't work; you would have to be Mike Mangini, because you only use your wrist with timpani. The tuba is honestly just a horrible sample, and I didn't like how the trumpet got to high in octave for ear-piercing lengths. I liked it though; one peice of advise would to be to press F9 when your on your FL music maker and click on one of the things on the right and add a reverb, then maybe put the preset to "the venue". I promise, it will make everything sound more realistic. I really liked the chords you used around the 2:20 and on. You know what you're doin', man, I'll give you that. Also, it's a march. Where's the beat on every quarter note, and the suprises? Don't be afraid to make your songs make you jump.

EmperorCharlemagne responds:

It's actually pretty embarassing to look back on this song I made a long time ago, back when I knew little about music and even less about FL Studio.

Believe you me, if I made this with the knowledge i had now, it would sound a whole lot less unbearable.

Thanks for the perspective of an actual musician; I appreciate the insight (again, if I had known that over a year ago... yikes!).

[Dream Runner Revampd-lidlurch-]

Pretty good

You can always expect the best of Garage Band from you, man. I loved the progressions, but I guess the synths really don't cut it. They're not that bad, you just need to tweak the presets to your liking. I do see a small problem; sometimes, I don't even notice a melody is going on. Maybe if the bells weren't screaming in my ears like some "IDM Vibraphone" for thirty seconds I wouldn't be so focused on how the drummer was pressing down the hi-hat while his two sticks ghostnoted on the drum and occasionally hit the hi-hat. I just suggest no picking such a messy synth for soloing, because it seems like "making it louder" wouldn't be a good idea around. It may just be some equalization and volume/padding (save that the padding is so the bass is practically on your right ear, like in a real orchestra!), but something made the solo with the bell at the end extremely unappealing.

Don't get me wrong, man, you make the best garage band stuff out there, but I can't leave you a review without any type of critisism!

lidlurch responds:

hmm...Interesting advice. I actually wanted to emphasize that solo, I liked it a lot :P oh well, those are some easy tweaks i could make for a different version. It's a really fun song to play around with ;) yeah, i'm still getting used to the new way i do drumming on garage band.. I don't even have to play it on the keyboard, so there you go! I actually turned the drums down so it wouldn't be so loud, but you know, it depends on the preference of the listener (did you notice the pulsing i put in the drums?). I think i'll keep it the way it is, maybe come back to it some other time... Oh, and btw, i actually changed the instruments up quite a bit, just listen to the original version i posted

Idk if you use garage band but do you know of any way that i could generate my own instruments rather than just tweaking preset ones?

great advice! thanks alot! let me know if you've got any new stuff :)

[Bass Crusher]

Transitions, transitions transitions!

There was only one real problem other then the generic sounding drums (and how it didn't have a cymbal constant) was transitions. It wasn't so much that new things came out randomly, but perhaps too quickly, or rather the new theme was too quick. The composition in general was great, though.

lidlurch responds:

yeah, it is a really quick song, so i might put in some longer transitions and some drums, if i can make them fit. I totally know what you mean though, and thanks for the review!

[ArcH - Cockjoke!]

THIS IS BLASPHEMY

How dare you taint the word "music" with this disguisting rabble, implimented with a grimy, simple four/four beat that has left our communities without a moral perspective on music-- thus destroying the art of music as a whole! The crude and primitive lyrics followed by a overpowering bassline had not made it better, and the treble was simply horrible and without real melody and progression!

Not really, of course; although music is (obviously) not usually with humour, when humour is implimented, it actually yields good results for professionals, but not so much with amatuers. Though people don't understand that most humour oriented music isn't exactly based upon the instruments. This is beside the point; the song was actually pretty impressive with the synths, and even if the bassline was used beforehand, it matched with the song and fit nicely. The vocals were actually impressive; I also liked the british accent, though correct me if I'm wrong. Another thing with the vocals were that they were on time; it's actually pretty hard to mash a bit of those letters in a small amount of time while still sounding good. Though, I must admit, the lyrics were a bit suggestive, I tend to ignore the specific vocals and soak in the cock-jokiness that repeats almost in an unending circle. Don't let getting top five dissuade you from continuing your music "career" here on Newgrounds, homes!

Archealor responds:

kthxbai

[Por su, mi amor]

It was okay.

It was really nice, but it felt like it needed some progression. It felt like it was the same thing over again, but I know it wasn't. With the volume variations, I think you need to work more on working up, because it feels too much like it's quiet and soft, but still quick, and then it's in your face instantly. My last complaint is with the bass notes; you hit four or five keys at one time and it didn't really sound that good.

Otherwise, it was really good, man. Keep it up!

lvl5drummer responds:

thanks dude! yeah chords are a little tricky for me so i'm working on those. and i'm actually trying to teach myself to play my songs so i can make sense and improve them. but thanks for the review!

<lvl5>